Return to PJ Online Home Page
The Pharmaceutical Journal Vol 265 No 7116 p484
September 30, 2000 Letters

Emollients

Simplistic approach

From Mr L. Furniss, MRPharmS, and others

SIR,—We were interested to read your report on a letter sent by the Skin Care Campaign to chief executives of primary care groups about the use of aqueous cream (PJ, September 2, p325). We would like to add the following comments regarding the use of emollients.
Choice of any therapy should consider safety, efficacy and cost-effectiveness and should be individualised to the patient. With respect to emollients, there is a lack of good quality evidence comparing preparations, and patients should use the cheapest one that is effective, cosmetically acceptable and which they are prepared to use regularly.1
Regarding the consistency of the product, individuals will obviously have different preferences. As a result we also suggest hydrous ointment BP, cetomacrogol cream BP, white soft paraffin 50 per cent/liquid paraffin 50 per cent and emulsifying ointment BP as options with varying consistencies. We would be interested in receiving information on patient satisfaction with aqueous cream at the address below.
We would also welcome any details of the “substantial” numbers of people who are sensitised to aqueous cream; recent information confirms that aqueous cream is suitable for many patients with dry skin.2
We entirely agree with the recommendation to encourage prescribing sufficient amounts of emollients to patients.1
We were disappointed at the simplistic approach to recommending emollients that was implied in the report, ie, that “pharmaceutical advisers to PCGs are inappropriately recommending aqueous cream as the emollient of choice because it is cheap”.
In summary, we will continue to promote the principles above to our general practitioners and will continue to suggest aqueous cream as a suitable option in the initial management of patients with dry skin.

 

Lee Furniss
Janet Cree
Sarah Taylor
Ian Tritschler
Prescribing Advisers to Primary Care Groups,
Camden & Islington NHS Health Authority,
110 Hampstead Road,
London NW1 2LJ

References

  1. National Prescribing Centre. The use of emollients in dry skin conditions. Merec Bull 1998;9:45-8.
  2. Royal Pharmaceutical Society/British Medical Association. British National Formulary (no 44). London: BMJ Books/Pharmaceutical Press; September, 2000.