Home > PJ  > Letters

Return to PJ Online Home Page

The Pharmaceutical Journal Vol 266 No 7152 p815-820
June 16, 2001

Letters

  RPM
  In-store pharmacies
  Pharmacy medicines
  Patient packs
  The Profession
  Future of pharmacy
  Coronary heart disease
  Influenza
  Checking technicians
  Dianette
  Paracetamol
  Monitored dosage systems
  Disillusioned youth
  Code of Ethics
  SGM
  Disposal of medicines
  Separate register
  Onlooker
  The Journal


Letters to the Editor

Onlooker

Samuel Johnson, Gaelic and pharmacy

From Mr F. M. Hickey, MRPharmS

As ever, “Onlooker” has interesting things to say, this time on political correctness (PJ, June 9, p768). It is unlikely, however, that he would have been able to draw his claymore in protest against Samuel Johnson’s remarks about Gaelic. The British Government had been actively “disarming” the Scottish Highlands for years. If he still had such a weapon it would have had to be retrieved from its traditional hiding place in the thatched roof of his cottage, assuming that his cottage still had a roof left following the attention of the British Army.

Dr Johnson’s remark was made at a time when merely wearing tartan (unless employed by the British Army) was punishable by transportation to “any of His Majesty’s plantations beyond the seas, there to remain for the space of seven years”, under the infamous Act of Proscription that was extant from 1747 to 1782. Official and popular prejudice still exists against Gaelic, which was once the language of all Scotland. Children of my grandparents’ generation were beaten for speaking it at school. It is only in recent years that the state has permitted it within schools.

And its relevance to pharmacy? The “History of Scottish medicine” by John D. Comrie (Wellcome Historical Museum, 1932) highlights many Gaelic medical manuscripts, the earliest dated being from 1403 but some probably older. These are in keeping with contemporary practice and include excerpts from Galen and Avicenna, familiar to us from our own Society’s coat of arms. If Dr Johnson had been unwell on his tour of the Highlands and Islands, it is likely that the medical man treating him would have done his thinking in Gaelic, but expressed himself, for his patient’s benefit, in the international language of medicine and prostitution, English.

Findlay Hickley
Edinburgh

 

Previous Topic (Separate register)
Next Topic (The Journal)
Send your letter to The Editor

Back to Top




©The Pharmaceutical Journal