Home > PJ (current issue) > Christmas Miscellany 2003 | Search

Return to PJ Online Home Page

The Pharmaceutical Journal
Vol 271 No 7280 p869-870
20/27 December 2003

This article
Reprint
Photocopy

   

PDF 130K


Christmas miscellany summary


Appendicitis on a grand, oriental scale

Ray Sturgess, MRPharmS, was the first pharmacist to live and work in Borneo and is writing a book on bizarre episodes in the history of medicine. Here is one of his stories, recounting the time he had to deal with a surgeon who believed he had an appendicitis epidemic on his hands


In volunteering to live and work in Borneo, I suppose I should have been prepared for the bizarre. I had been trying to settle back in England after giving up my job in Hong Kong as manager of the only British-owned pharmacy there. But dispensing NHS prescriptions seemed tame after the Far East and one Friday I turned to the overseas situations vacant section of The Journal. There was just one advertisement, under the heading “Sarawak”. On impulse I typed an application and posted it the next morning. That lunch time I went along to the library in Exeter to find out where Sarawak was. Somewhat to my surprise, I discovered that it was situated in the north western corner of Borneo. The country had, until 1947, been ruled by members of the Brooke family of Devon, referred to as the “white rajahs”. Head-hunting by the Dyaks, the main indigenous race in Borneo, had been common until the 1930s when, after a long struggle by the Brookes, it was thought to have been eradicated, although there was a resurgence during the Japanese occupation in the 1939–45 war, encouraged from 1945 onwards by the Allied guerillas dropped behind the Japanese lines.

After the Japanese surrender, the last of the rajahs, Vyner Brooke, returned to Sarawak, and soon realising the impossibility of putting the country back on its feet with the slender resources at his disposal, he handed the country over to the British government. The Labour government of the time was more concerned with getting rid of its legacy of British colonies than with acquiring new ones, but the tradition of upholding the white man’s burden was strong, and plenty of old colonial hands responded to the call.

Sarawak’s new director of medical services, Dr W. Glyn Evans, appointed in 1953, had served in Malaya since the early 1930s. He had been imprisoned by the Japanese in the notorious Changi camp on Singapore island and survived. Glyn Evans had a high opinion of pharmacists, the two who had been with him in Changi having rigged up a soil elutriation plant that produced as the end product a light powder that was used as a substitute for kaolin in treating the ever-present dysentery cases. Glyn Evans had been used to having government pharmacists working with him in Malaya and had advertised for one for Sarawak.

By the time I arrived I thought I had done my homework. I was prepared for daytime temperatures in the 90s that fell only to about 85F at night, and for humidity that was mostly around 90 per cent. I knew that there was only one stretch of asphalted road outside the capital, Kuching, where I was to be stationed, and that all medical supplies were distributed by river and sea. I was fully prepared to share my house space with mosquitoes and its walls with lizards and geckos. I was not alarmed, even when switching on a light in the evening produced an instant invasion of flying “ants” (in reality, termites of the order Isoptera), which crashed into the light bulbs, immediately shedding their wings, and then crawling all over the floor and furniture. But a hospital full of appendicitis patients? That was not on my list.

Gerald Pinsent

Dr Gerald Pinsent arrived a few months after me. My memories of arriving in a strange country and staying in the impersonal government rest house were still fresh, so I invited him and his wife to dinner. The Pinsents were Anglo-Indians, handsome and impressively tall. We got on well and, after their diet of endless curries in the rest house, they liked my cook’s chicken pie. A few days later the Pinsents moved on to Sibu, Sarawak’s second town, where Gerald was taking over as the new divisional medical officer. I was due to visit the Sibu hospital to meet the dispensary staff and, after giving the Pinsents time to settle in, I flew over. After I had met my Sibu staff and checked that all was in order in the dispensary, Gerald Pinsent invited me to the operating theatre to watch an appendectomy. After the patient was anaesthetised he made a tiny incision at McBurney’s point and fished around inside with his little finger before producing a surprisingly grey-looking appendix which he then ligatured and snipped off. He was obviously proud of his skill, and claimed that the incision was an only an inch and a half long. It was certainly small; the only other appendectomy scar I had seen had been about three times the length.

Gerald had another area of expertise, with the camera. He enthused over the photogenic potential of the mighty Rejang river, well over a mile wide at Sibu and busy with exotic river traffic that included Chinese junks, Malay proas and Dyak dugout canoes. From the impressive photographs he showed me, it was clear that photography was a consuming interest. He had been lucky, he said, in finding a photographic supplier in Sibu, a Mr Chakravarty, who stocked a wide range of supplies and equipment. An even greater boon was that Mr Chakravarty had offered Gerald the use of his darkroom whenever he needed it.

I had been back in Kuching a month or two when the first request for extra cylinders of nitrous oxide anaesthetic gas came from Sibu. It was inconvenient, since our anaesthetic gases arrived in a monthly shipment from Singapore, and there would be a delay in replacing them. However, since Gerald was obviously working flat out in the operating theatre and corresponding with him would have caused a delay (there was no telephone link with Sibu at that time), I sent the cylinders without query. A week later the monthly indent arrived from Sibu hospital and it included double the usual number of nitrous oxide cylinders. By then we had increased our own monthly order from Singapore and, concluding that Gerald was catching up with a backlog of surgery (there had been a some months between the departure of his predecessor and Gerald’s arrival), I sent the additional cylinders. Within days of the delivery, I received a telegram at the office. “Urgent,” it read, “Please send 12 nitrous oxide by first vessel. Appendicitis epidemic in Sibu. D.M.O.”

The mention of an epidemic set off alarm bells and I knew that it was time to alert my boss, Glyn Evans. When I showed him the telegram, he snorted and shouted through to his Malay clerk to book him on the afternoon plane to Sibu. Soon after I got home from the office the next day, there was a telephone call from the rest house in Kuching. It was Gerald Pinsent: “Glyn Evans has suspended me. He’s sending us home.” I feigned shock, but I had seen Glyn Evans that morning, after his return from Sibu, and I knew the verdict. To the demoralised Pinsents, “Come round for dinner”, was all I could say.

A procedure to increase virility

Glyn Evans had a nice Celtic sense of the dramatic. He told me how, when he had got to the Sibu hospital, he had found a ward full of Chinese men, with more lolling on chairs in the corridor. He had gone down the ward prodding each patient in his abdomen. No one had yelled, presumably being mesmerised by the appearance of a pugnacious supremo in their midst. Glyn Evans had said at each bed to the ward sister in tow, “Out!” He half grinned at me in explanation, “You know what it’s all about, don’t you?” I had no idea. “Chinese men think that having the appendix removed makes them more virile.” He was right but what he said applied, of course, only to uneducated Chinese in this part of South East Asia.

This was a new angle on Chinese aphrodisiacs. I knew that the list of things that Chinese men believe would act as sexual stimulants was endless, the most notorious being the powdered horn of the white rhinoceros. Another example had stared at me when the P&O liner carrying me to Singapore on the way to Sarawak had put in at Penang, where huge billboards proclaimed the merits of Waterbury’s Compound. This was a bogus tonic I vaguely remembered as being on the scene in the early days of pharmacy but which had long since disappeared in the United Kingdom. Its popularity in Malaya rested on the bright idea of the local agent who had suggested in the advertisements that it had aphrodisiac properties. Appendectomy as an aphrodisiac took some believing, but Glyn Evans was an old Far East hand, with over 20 years’ service in Malaya and there was not much he did not know about the Chinese and aphrodisiacs, and a lot more besides.

When the Pinsents came to dinner that evening we did not discuss the Chinese connection between appendectomies and aphrodisiacs. Instead, I listened to Gerald’s protestations that his appendectomy patients, although all Chinese, male, and between 30 and 60 years old, had presented with the three diagnostic symptoms for appendicitis: severe pain at McBurney’s point, an elevated white cell count and a raised temperature. He really believed that his overflowing ward of patients had somehow contracted appendicitis on an epidemic scale. I could not help thinking that common sense should have told him that this was unrealistic. Appendicitis is not contagious, does not come in epidemics, and no infections specifically select Chinese men aged between 30 and 60. I felt sure that the colonial office medical board, which would be reviewing his case, would think so too.

Gerald was, in due course, suspended by the colonial office and required to leave the service. I did not hear again from the Pinsents and, in the circumstances, I had not expected to. I spent much time pondering the affair. I had believed Gerald when he told me he had seen evidence of two of the symptoms of appendicitis, the raised temperatures and white cell counts. As to the third symptom, it was obvious that men anxious to boost their sex lives would convincingly simulate abdominal pain.

Raised body temperature

I later found out that the Chinese had the means of raising their body temperatures. John Menon, the doctor who replaced Gerald, became a good friend and on one occasion, when I was staying with him he said that he was going to the hospital to see a 10-year old boy who had a raging fever, dry burning skin, dilated pupils, but no symptoms of infection. The boy’s parents admitted that they had been to the druggist in Sibu and had been given some herbs. They had brewed them in hot water and dosed their son with the resulting infusion. Would I go with him, John asked, and see what I thought. When we got there the boy’s temperature was 108F. He was delirious and critically ill and we agreed that the symptoms were those of poisoning by an atropine-like substance. The boy’s parents were there and John got a Chinese nurse to ask them if they had any of the herbs left. They said that they had used them all. John arranged for the treatment he had instigated earlier in the day, pilocarpine by intravenous infusion, to be continued and we left for the house of a Chinese police inspector who could help us find out what herbs had been supplied.

By now it was after midnight and the druggist’s shop was battened down for the night. After prolonged banging on the door, a light went on and the herbalist appeared. A Chinese man and his wife had called yesterday for medicine for their son, the inspector explained. Would he please let us have exactly what he had supplied them with. The herbalist went to several drawers in the shop and extracted dried herbs from each, which he put into brown paper and handed over. I took charge of the packet until I could get it airmailed to Singapore for analysis. The inspector now told the druggist that the boy was seriously ill and warned him that in future he should only dispense herbs that were safe. Although I had been in Sarawak a few months, I was liaising with the government legal department and gradually introducing medicines safety legislation based on UK precedents, but these could not be applied to Chinese herbalists because of the difficulty of identifying the traditional drugs, a problem that is still far from being solved today.

By morning the boy was dead. A week later the report came from the analytical laboratory to say that stramonium, a poisonous herb (known in Britain as thornapple) containing atropine and the equally deadly hyoscyamine, had been in the packet. All we could do was to get the government health inspectors to issue warnings to Chinese druggists to limit severely the quantities of potent herbs sold at any one time. This experience took me back to Gerald’s appendicitis patients and the possibility, since they had access to Chinese drug stores, that they had taken stramonium in small amounts to produce convincingly high temperatures. It was possible but unlikely, I thought, since their dilated pupils would have given the game away.

A more likely explanation

A year or so later a more likely explanation came to light. John Menon was called by the police in connection with a murder inquiry and asked to take samples of suspected bloodstains found on the walls of the house where the victim had met her end. John and I corresponded on a weekly basis and he kept me informed of the progress of the case. In one letter he told me that there had been a sensation during the trial when, Tan Bin Law, the chief technician of his pathology lab, was obliged to admit that he had not carried out the blood tests. I knew Bin Law, since before he had been posted to Sibu he had been a regular at the badminton club in Kuching where I played most nights. He was easily overawed, frightened even, and although he was a more skilled badminton player than I, he usually let me win. I told John that I was sure that he must have been threatened by relatives of the accused and been frightened into silence.

Bin Law had been in charge of the pathology laboratory at Sibu hospital at the time of the appendicitis epidemic, and I now saw a possible explanation for the raised white cell counts that Gerald had relied upon. It would only have needed one Chinese man, desperate to boost his virility and with some knowledge of hospital procedures, to have threatened Bin Law for the timorous technician to have obliged. Once he had succumbed, Bin Law would have been blackmailed into performing the same service for others wanting an appendectomy. Bribes or threats could have also made the ward nurse produce the high temperature readings.

Gerald Pinsent had complied with medical practice in requiring raised temperatures and white cell counts to confirm appendicitis, but he ought to have become suspicious when Chinese men, all aged between 30 and 60, started flooding into the hospital. The keys to Gerald’s lack of awareness were his eagerness to perform appendectomies and the narrowness of his socialising. For company, influenced by his Anglo-Indian background and his passion for photography, he had relied exclusively on Mr Chakravarty. The small expatriate community in Sibu had always enlarged their social circle by befriending the leaders of the local Chinese community. Chinese friends are loyal, and regard it as their duty to save any of their circle from losing face. Had Gerald made friends with the local Chinese, they would have alerted him to the reason for the rush of male patients with abdominal pain, the only appendicitis epidemic in the annals of medicine.

Back to Top


Home | Journals | News | Notice-board | Search | Jobs  Classifieds | Site Map | Contact us

©The Pharmaceutical Journal