Home > PJ (current issue) > Letters | Search

PJ Online homeThe Pharmaceutical Journal
Vol 273 No 7307 p53
10 July 2004

This article
Reprint   Photocopy

PDF 100K, Acrobat Reader

Letters

· Pharmacy education
· St John's wort
· Dispensing
· Antimicrobial resistance
· The Conference
· NHS Confederation
· The profession
· The Society
· The Journal


Letters to the Editor

Dispensing

Law appears to allow generic substitution by drug companies

From Mrs C. J. Hutchinson, MRPharmS

We all know that a prescription for a branded product requires the supply of that branded product. At no point is generic substitution even an option. However, it appears that pharmaceutical companies can do it and have the law on their side. I refer to the product Innovace 5mg, its parallel import and the branded generic Rinetec (enalapril, also made by Merck).

Recently, a customer returned a packet of parallel-imported Innovace saying that the contents were not Innovace. On examining the pack, I found it contained Rinetec foils which had been overlabelled “Innovace”. My supplier contacted the licence holder, who said that since the product was made by the same company and the leaflet referred to all three variants (Innovace, Rinetec and enalapril), this was permitted within the licence.

I then contacted the Royal Pharmaceutical Society which referred my query to the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency. I received a reply which quoted licensing law, also stating that the product was legal since it met the criteria for equivalence to the original brand.

I then questioned my local inspector, who said she was aware that such products existed but this was nothing to do with the Society. She said that if I thought the product was unethical then I could refuse to use it. (Great, I thought, but I bet I will not be paid to use the British product.)

Has anyone else come across this problem? Am I making a mountain out of a molehill? Does the (unintentional) supply of Rinetec constitute a dispensing error in that what the GP wanted has not been supplied? I have, after all, had boxes of Rinetec on the shelf but only used them for enalapril prescriptions. Other opinions would be gratefully received (e-mail carol@hutchinson family.freeserve.co.uk).

Carol Hutchinson
Rugby, Warwickshire

Send your letter to The Editor

Previous Topic (St John's wort)
Next Topic (Antimicrobial resistance)

Back to Top


©The Pharmaceutical Journal