AZ follows Pfizer into direct-to-pharmacy distribution
AstraZeneca this week confirmed that it would adopt a direct-to-pharmacy model to distribute its medicines within the UK, using two wholesalers — AAH Pharmaceuticals and UniChem — as its “agency partners”.
AstraZeneca says that by appointing two agents choice is maintained,
minimising disruption to customers.
Last year, in response to UniChem’s single-distributor arrangement
with Pfizer, AAH managing director Steve Dunn said that AAH had put the
interests of its customers first by refusing to sign a deal with Pfizer
that would create an unprecedented and monopolistic stranglehold on the
market. He told The Journal then that Pfizer’s arrangement would
be a disruption to
the usual supply chain and create multiple invoices
and deliveries for pharmacists (PJ, 7 October 2006, p413).
However, Mr Dunn defended AAH’s deal with AstraZeneca at the group’s
convention this week in Singapore: “AAH supports manufacturers
in their desire to evolve their business models. We wish to work with
manufacturers to ensure that this happens in a mutually beneficial way;
but we will not support solutions which put at risk the integrity of
the supply chain or which are implemented to the detriment of pharmacy
and pharmacists.” Mr Dunn confirmed AAH’s continued opposition
to a single-distributor model (see
below).
David Coles, managing director, UniChem, said that UniChem’s involvement
ensures “ease of ordering and frequency of delivery via a tried
and tested logistics infrastructure”.
Scottish Pharmaceutical General Council chairman Martin Green said: “SPGC
is extremely disappointed at the timing of AstraZeneca’s announcement
following on so closely from the notice of intent by the Office of Fair
Trading to conduct a market review of medicines distribution in the UK.
We feel, it would have been better if AstraZeneca had waited until the
OFT had completed its review before taking these steps.”
John D’Arcy, National Pharmacy Association chief executive, said: “Our
members will now have another layer of administration to deal with, distracting
them from patient care. We would also disagree with AZ’s assertion
that choice is maintained. With only two wholesalers included choice
is definitely reduced. This is a further nail in the coffin for the smaller
wholesalers.”
Lindsay McClure, head of information services at the Pharmaceutical Services
Negotiating Committee, told The Journal: “No information is yet
available on proposed discount terms. The national contract guarantees
community pharmacy £500m income from buying profit, measured at
the level of independent pharmacy, and it is a major priority for PSNC
to ensure that this funding is delivered. PSNC is seeking to meet with
AstraZeneca at the earliest opportunity.” Community Pharmacy Wales
also said that it wished to discuss the proposals with AstraZeneca.
AstraZeneca intends to implement its distribution model late in the summer.
Findings from the OFT
short market study (PJ, 14 April, p415) are expected
by the end of the year.
Phoenix response
Phoenix, the UK’s third-largest wholesaler, has not been included
in the AstraZeneca deal. The wholesaler said in a statement that
the decision “inflicts further serious damage on the Phoenix
UK wholesale business and potentially brings into question the future
viability of our comprehensive full-line service”.
Phoenix said that it engaged in “lengthy commercial negotiations” with
AstraZeneca, and believed it was in the final stages of agreeing
a legal contract that was being co-ordinated with a number of other
distributors.
But Phoenix claims: “The fact that AZ has now decided to
dramatically reduce the number of distributors would suggest to
us that this process
is more about manipulation and control of their market than wanting
a more orderly approach to distribution.”
Alex MacKinnon, head of corporate affairs, SPGC, said: “We
question how a proposal which excludes the UK’s other main
full-line wholesaler, Phoenix, can be in the best interest of community
pharmacists and their patients. We have concerns about how this
will impact on the future of regional wholesalers.” |
|